Wednesday, January 9, 2008

My Thoughts About Reviews

Today was a very uneventful day. I've been playing this card game with my family called My Word!. It's a fast paced spelling game that inevitably causes verbal bashings.

Anyway, back to the original point. I have been thinking a lot of how I want to do the ratings. Do I rate by song or album? Do I do percentages or stars (and if so how man stars)? What categories do I rate? But then, I read a review of Everything Starts Where It Ends by Lovedrug at this link. And here's the artist's response*:

Dear Mr./Miss TrustxDialect,
I thank you dearly for this gem of advice into my now knowingly trite and useless dream of a career waisted for the past 10 years . You obviously put alot of thought into this and must know more about music than most. To think, I waisted all those years of putting my personal thoughts and feelings into these songs that I slaved over writing; and it took you only two easy listens to figure out that it was all just mindless bullshit. Man, I wish I had your insight. Well, thanks again. And if I decide to attempt to make another album I'll try not to let you down again.

Sincerely,
Michael Shepard
So this got me to thinking that bands have real people in them too. If I had someone critique everything that I did, my feelings would get hurt as well. I give Mike kudos for sticking up for his beliefs. So going along with that, I will only give non-hateful reviews. If I write a review it means that I already like the thing that I am reviewing. Any comment should be taken as my own personal feelings and should no way be taken as offensive.

*originally found on AbsolutePunk.net

No comments: